What does the evidence say?
Planned Home Birth: Safety and Outcomes
Research on planned home births attended by midwives has found low rates of medical intervention and favorable outcomes among low-risk women. A 2005 study published in the BMJ followed more than 5,000 women planning home births with Certified Professional Midwives, while a 2014 study examined outcomes from nearly 17,000 planned home births in the United States. A more recent study published in 2024 compared planned home births with births in freestanding birth centers and found generally comparable outcomes among low-risk pregnancies. These studies focus on planned, midwife-attended births rather than combining them with accidental or unattended home births, an important distinction when evaluating the research.
An important part of planning a home birth is knowing when additional medical care may be needed and having a plan for hospital transfer. In the 2014 study of nearly 17,000 planned home births, approximately 11% of women transferred to the hospital during labor, most commonly because labor was not progressing. Transfers were more common among first-time mothers, and more than half of the women who transferred gave birth vaginally. The Home Birth Summit's Best Practice Guidelines emphasize communication and collaboration between midwives and hospital providers to support safe, respectful transfers when additional care is needed.
Midwifery Care and Informed Decision-Making
Research on midwifery-led care has found benefits including fewer medical interventions and greater satisfaction with the birth experience. An important part of midwifery care is having the time to ask questions, discuss your options, and make informed decisions about your care.
The Rights of Childbearing Women outlines the importance of respectful maternity care, including the right to clear information about the benefits and risks of recommended treatments, the right to accept or decline interventions, and the right to participate in decisions about your own care.
Continuity of care is another important benefit of the midwifery model. Having an established relationship with your midwife throughout pregnancy, birth, and the postpartum period means receiving care from someone who knows you and your history. A 2024 Cochrane review of more than 18,000 women found that midwife continuity-of-care models were associated with fewer cesarean births, more spontaneous vaginal births, and more positive experiences with maternity care.
Labor and Birth Practices
Research supports a number of practices that allow labor to progress naturally while supporting the health and comfort of both mother and baby. The World Health Organization's recommendations for childbirth support eating and drinking during labor, freedom of movement and choice of birth position, and intermittent fetal monitoring for healthy women with uncomplicated pregnancies.
Continuous support during labor can make a meaningful difference in the birth experience. A Cochrane review of 26 studies involving nearly 16,000 women found that women receiving continuous one-on-one support were more likely to give birth vaginally without intervention, less likely to need pain medication or cesarean birth, and more likely to report positive birth experiences. Comfort measures such as massage, position changes, warm water, and emotional support can also help women cope with labor.
Water immersion during labor can help with pain management and reduce the need for epidural anesthesia. Research on water birth has also found benefits, including fewer interventions and high levels of maternal satisfaction, while identifying some risks that should be considered when making an informed decision.
Delayed umbilical cord clamping allows additional blood to pass from the placenta to the baby after birth and has benefits for newborn iron stores.
Newborn Care and the First Hours After Birth
The first hours after birth are an important time for both mother and baby. Research supports immediate, uninterrupted skin-to-skin contact, which helps newborns regulate their temperature and blood sugar, supports their transition to life outside the womb, and increases the likelihood of successful breastfeeding. The World Health Organization recommends keeping mothers and babies together and supporting breastfeeding within the first hour after birth.
Parents also have important decisions to make about routine newborn care. Understanding the benefits and risks of vitamin K administration is one example. Evidence Based Birth provides a thorough discussion of vitamin K deficiency bleeding, the effectiveness of the newborn vitamin K injection, and the available alternatives.
More Topics to Explore
There are many decisions to make throughout pregnancy, birth, and the postpartum period. These resources offer more information about some of the questions we commonly discuss during prenatal visits.
Group B Strep (GBS) — Screening, treatment options, and the evidence behind antibiotics during labor.
When your water breaks before labor begins — Research on waiting for labor to begin versus inducing labor at term.
Breastfeeding — Practical, evidence-based information about breastfeeding and common challenges.
Infant sleep and bedsharing — Research and information about infant sleep arrangements and reducing risks.
Circumcision — Research on the normal anatomy and function of the foreskin, the evidence surrounding infant circumcision, and questions of consent and bodily integrity.
Herbs and natural approaches during pregnancy — Information about complementary approaches, including their potential benefits and safety considerations.
